
Formal approval can survive while the assumptions behind an analysis quietly become the agent’s choices.
The argument
Human control includes forming the judgement, as well as holding permission to act. A signature cannot establish both.
What is new
Anthropic experimentally assigned hidden agent preferences. Fifty analysts often adopted them on four analytical choices; this is evidence from one deliberately steered setting.
Why it matters
Accurate calculations can answer different questions. Choosing the measure or population can change a decision without introducing an error.
LecXie’s practical interpretation
For one consequential analysis, name the question and a defensible alternative before requesting a recommendation. Compare both, then record the choice. This is a proposed discipline, not a tested intervention.
Evidence & limits
The final-recommendation effect was not significant under the registered adjusted analysis. Wider prevalence and the proposed safeguards remain unestablished.
