EducationExpert opinion · 22 October 2026
Learning that survives without the tool
Beth M. Schwartz and Christopher Hakala
APA senior director and cognitive psychologist; Springfield College learning-science researcher
- The argument
- Established learning science can guide AI use before tool-specific evidence matures. Protect the mental work required for the intended learning.
- What is new
- The useful test is not merely better assisted work. Can students demonstrate and transfer understanding without AI afterwards?
- Why it matters
- A polished assignment and durable learning are different outcomes.
LecXie’s practical interpretationTry an unaided attempt, AI feedback and an explanation of the student's choices. Then assess a new task without assistance.
Evidence & limitsExpert interpretation, not a new AI trial or quantified benefit. The authors call for small studies across disciplines and learner populations. Our suggested sequence is a testable design, not a proven intervention.